Short answer: most insulation notes in a Long Island inspection report fall into three groups. Some need attention before any insulation work: wet insulation, signs of mold, possible vermiculite, vents blowing into the attic, or knob-and-tube wiring. Some are ordinary upgrades: thin or settled attic insulation, open kneewalls, bare rim joists. And some are just "not accessible," which means nobody looked. An insulation contractor can tell the buyer or seller what's actually there and what it would take, but only with access to the attic and crawl space. In New York, an inspector can't take a fee from a contractor for work the inspector reported on.
I'm Joe Giordano, and I've insulated homes in Nassau and Suffolk since 2004. This page is for real estate agents, home inspectors and the buyers and sellers they work with. If you're a builder, GC or property manager, see the builder section of our new construction page: I quote from plans.
What do common insulation notes in an inspection report mean?
"Insufficient" or "thin" attic insulation
The most common note. It usually means old insulation that has settled, been disturbed, or was never very deep. On its own it isn't a defect, it's an upgrade opportunity. For context, the 2025 New York energy code lists R-49 for ceilings with an attic, and ENERGY STAR publishes recommended levels for existing attics. A contractor can measure what's there and compare.
Wet, stained or compressed insulation
That's a symptom. Something above it is leaking, or warm, moist air is getting into the attic. ENERGY STAR lists wet or damp insulation and moldy or rotted framing among the conditions to have corrected by a professional before any attic project. Fix the roof or the leak first, then deal with the insulation. See when to remove old attic insulation.
Possible vermiculite
Vermiculite is a pebble-like, pour-in insulation, usually gray-brown or silver-gold. EPA advises assuming it may contain asbestos, not disturbing it, and using a trained professional if it has to be removed. Nobody should add insulation over it or start work in that attic until the owner has decided how to handle it. New York's Property Condition Disclosure Statement asks the seller whether there's asbestos in the structure.
Bath, kitchen or dryer vents into the attic
ENERGY STAR lists vents that exhaust moist air into the attic instead of outdoors as a problem to fix before insulating. Venting is usually a separate trade.
Knob-and-tube wiring
ENERGY STAR notes that knob-and-tube wiring can be a fire hazard in contact with insulation. That's a question for a licensed electrician before any insulation goes near it.
Open kneewalls, bare rim joists, a cold room over the garage
Common in Capes, high-ranches and split-levels, and usually straightforward to fix. See where Long Island houses lose heat and cold room over the garage.
"Not accessible" or "not evaluated"
Inspectors report on what's readily accessible. New York's rules for home inspectors say they may only report on readily accessible and observed conditions. A sealed-off top attic in a Cape, or a crawl space with no hatch, may never have been looked at. That's worth a second look, not an assumption.
What do New York's rules say about inspectors and contractors?
Home inspectors are licensed by the New York Department of State, and the law draws clear lines. Under Real Property Law section 444-g, a home inspector can't perform or offer to perform repairs or improvements, for an additional fee, on a home they've reported on before closing. The Department of State's code of ethics for home inspectors also says inspectors can't accept commissions, fees or other consideration from contractors in connection with work they've reported on, and can't compensate agents or brokers for referrals. The code also says inspectors don't determine code compliance.
So the inspector's job ends at the report. If a client asks who does insulation, an inspector can point them to contractors, but can't be paid by the contractor for it.
How can a buyer or seller get an insulation estimate during a sale?
My estimates are free. I go into the attic and crawl space, measure what's there, and use a thermal camera to show where the heat is going. Then I explain what I'd recommend and why. To do that I need:
- Access. Someone has to let me into the house, the attic and the crawl space. During a sale that means the seller agrees to the visit.
- The inspection notes, if the client is willing to share them. Photos of the attic help too, and you can text them to (631) 492-0214.
- Time. Call or text early, and I'll tell you when I can get there.
I'll tell you plainly if a note in the report isn't an insulation problem, or if something like a roof leak, mold or wiring has to be handled first.
What shouldn't anyone promise a buyer?
- Energy savings. Results depend on the house, the heating system and how people live in it. Be wary of any fixed savings figure.
- Rebates. We don't do rebate-program work, so check with the program directly. Our Long Island energy rebates guide lists where to look.
- Code status. Whether past work was permitted, or whether the house meets code, is a question for the building department. See our Long Island building department directory.
Frequently asked questions
Do you work with property managers and commercial buildings?
Yes, and commercial work is welcome. See commercial insulation.
How do I check a contractor's license?
Nassau and Suffolk both license home improvement contractors. See how to choose an insulation contractor on Long Island.
Where do you work?
All of Nassau and Suffolk, including Fire Island by ferry and Shelter Island, and sometimes Queens and NYC, especially for commercial work. See our service areas.
Send me a report or a question
Call or text me at (631) 492-0214, Monday to Saturday, 7 AM to 7 PM. I answer my own phone and call back the same day. Or have your client request a free estimate.